Start free

Crew Utilization in Construction: How to Measure and Improve It

Construction crew installing exterior wall sheathing

Crew utilization is the share of a crew’s paid hours that goes into productive, billable work. To improve it, you need three things: one clear formula, field data that arrives the same day, and a schedule that moves crews between jobs without gaps. Most contractors lose utilization in the handoffs between estimating, scheduling, payroll and the field, so one system that connects those handoffs does more than another spreadsheet tab. Below you will find the math, a worked example, the causes of low utilization, and a routine you can run every week.

Designflow-build
designflow-build.com
Bring Crew Data Into One System
DesignFlow Build connects project management, accounting, and field operations to help contractors manage crew hours and job data in one platform.
Visit

TL;DR

Table of Contents

What crew utilization means (and what it does not)

Utilization is the proportion of time a resource is in productive use. For a crew, it answers one question: of the hours we paid for, how many went into work that moves the job forward?

It is easy to confuse with two neighbors:

The three connect. One planning and controls guide gives the relationship: productivity factor equals efficiency rate times utilization. That makes the pairing useful for diagnosis:

That split saves you from the most common mistake: pushing a crew to work harder when the real problem is that it is standing around.

One caution from the same textbook. A utilization number for a single person can mislead. A welding inspector at 100% utilization can still cause waste across the site if welders wait for inspections, and adding an inspector may pay off even if he is not always busy. Read utilization for the crew and the job, not only the individual.

How to calculate crew utilization

The formula is simple. The discipline is in deciding what counts as available time and what counts as productive time.

Crew utilization = productive hours ÷ available hours × 100

Step 1: Decide what “available” means

There are two defensible bases, and you should pick one and keep it.

  1. Paid hours. Everything on the timecard. This shows the true cost of idle time.
  2. Realistically available hours. Paid hours minus holidays, PTO, training, safety meetings and weather downtime.

The labor capacity guide shows how large the gap is. A carpenter paid for 2,080 hours a year is realistically available for 1,712 billable hours after 80 holiday hours, 80 PTO hours, 104 training and safety hours and 104 weather and downtime hours. That is 82% of paid time, which is why 100% is never the right goal.

Step 2: Decide what counts as productive

The Construction Industry Institute (CII) calls the time craft workers spend on actual construction direct work, also known as tool time or wrench time. Its Guide to Activity Analysis splits observations into seven categories: direct work, preparatory work, tools and equipment, material handling, waiting, travel and personal.

For weekly management, most contractors use a simpler rule: hours coded to a job and a cost code are productive, and hours coded to waiting, rework, travel between sites or unassigned time are not.

Step 3: Run a worked example

Here is an illustration with made-up numbers. A six-person MEP crew works a 40-hour week.

Item Hours
Paid hours (6 × 40) 240
Coded to installation on active jobs 156
Coded to prep, material pickup and travel 48
Waiting on drawings, access or inspection 24
Unassigned 12

If you count only installation hours, utilization is 156 ÷ 240 = 65%. If you count installation plus prep and pickup as productive, it is 204 ÷ 240 = 85%. Both numbers are useful. The first tells you how much time reaches the work face. The second tells you how well the crew is booked.

The 36 hours of waiting and unassigned time are the ones to chase. At a loaded labor cost of, say, $60 an hour, that is $2,160 in one week from one crew. The loaded rate here is an assumption, so use your own.

Step 3: Run a worked example

Step 4: Read the number against a range

The same guide recommends 75% to 85% for construction field labor. Below 70% it flags too many employees for the workload or poor scheduling, which leaves overhead unabsorbed. Above 90% it flags overbooking, overtime, burnout, quality problems and safety incidents. Treat that as a working range for your own history, not a law. A seasonal service crew and a ground-up commercial crew will sit in different places.

Why utilization drops on real jobs

The numbers from field studies are sobering. A 2007 workflow analysis of three production homes in Gilbert, Arizona, found that of 1,200 available work hours, an average of only 304 hours, or 25%, was used, and no work happened on 45 of 120 working days.

Why utilization drops on real jobs

A 2006 work sampling study at a hospital project in the southeastern US sorted 535 observations into three buckets: 40% productive work, 33% supportive work such as measuring, and 27% non-productive time such as waiting for instructions. Those are older studies of specific projects, so do not use them as your benchmark. They show the pattern: a large share of paid time disappears into small delays.

The causes you will recognize:

The last cause is the one software can remove. The first five need decisions, but the decisions depend on seeing the problem on the day it happens.

A weekly routine to raise utilization

The CII research gives a structure worth borrowing. Activity analysis is a continuous cycle of observation, finding improvement areas, implementing changes and reassessing. In CII’s 2009 studies, the project that applied it continuously reached significantly higher direct-work rates, as the Guide to Activity Analysis summarizes. You can run a lighter version every week.

  1. Pull last week’s hours by crew and job. Split them into productive, supporting and idle.
  2. Find the top two idle causes. Waiting for information and waiting for materials are the usual winners.
  3. Assign an owner and a fix. One person, one date. For example, a foreman confirms material delivery 48 hours before a task starts.
  4. Look ahead three weeks. Compare crew capacity with scheduled work. Move crews before a gap or a pile-up appears.
  5. Recheck next week. If the number did not move, the cause was wrong.

If you ever sample the field by direct observation, the sample needs to be big enough to trust. A location-based work sampling study that followed the CII guide required at least 84 observations per hour for a site of 50 to 100 workers, and collected 2,885 samples over six days. The 2006 hospital study authors also recommend that an outside party run the sampling, to reduce bias. For most contractors, daily coded time from the field gets you most of the value at far lower effort.

Watch the overtime trap

Chasing 95% utilization backfires. CII’s study of innovative crew scheduling surveyed nearly 1,300 contractors, owners and union representatives and analyzed productivity data from over 100 US projects. It built a model linking productivity to the average hours per crew member per week and to total project hours. The takeaway for your planning: hours per person per week is a variable you should manage deliberately, not a number that falls out of the schedule.

Compare like with like

CII’s benchmarking program has collected productivity data from over 200 projects since 2002, as its productivity benchmarking summary explains, so that teams can compare against peers. Your own trend is still the most reliable yardstick. Compare a crew with its own last quarter on similar work, and note conditions such as weather, access and design changes before you draw conclusions.

Where project management software earns its place

A spreadsheet can calculate utilization once. It struggles to keep it current. The problems are structural:

When field hours, cost codes, the schedule and payroll sit in one system, utilization becomes a report you open rather than a project you run. For the planning side, see our guides on resource leveling with live crew data and scheduling MEP crews across multiple jobs. If you want the wider workforce picture, commercial construction workforce planning and MEP workforce productivity practices go deeper.

Here is what each step of the routine looks like in DesignFlow Build:

Our perspective

We built DesignFlow Build because contractors told us the same story: the schedule is in one tool, the hours are in another, and the job cost report is a week behind. Utilization suffers in that gap. A foreman cannot move a crew on Tuesday using data that shows up on Friday.

Our view is that utilization is not a labor problem. It is a visibility problem. Crews are rarely idle because they are unwilling. They are idle because nobody saw the access issue, the late material or the open slot soon enough.

That is why we put project management, accounting and field operations into one system rather than selling another add-on. Contractors who replace Excel and disconnected accounting tools with one platform get one set of numbers, and one set of numbers is what makes a utilization conversation short. Our implementation takes 2 to 4 weeks, with no army of consultants, so you can start measuring on live jobs quickly.

Keith

Start measuring crew utilization in one platform

If you already track hours, the quickest win is to connect them to your schedule and cost codes. DesignFlow Build offers a free plan with core features. The Pro plan is $100 per month per office user, and Field seats are $25 per month per user, so crews in the field can log time without an office license. Our platform replaces the mix of spreadsheets and separate accounting and project tools with one system built for construction, and teams self-implement in 2 to 4 weeks.

Designflow-build

See the plans and seat options on our pricing page, or look at how the construction project management module ties crews, schedules and costs together.

FAQ

What is a good crew utilization rate in construction?

A common working range for field labor is 75% to 85% of paid time, according to a labor capacity planning guide. Below 70% suggests too few jobs or poor scheduling for the crew size, and above 90% suggests overbooking and overtime. Use it as a starting point, then set your own target from your trade and your past jobs.

Is crew utilization the same as productivity?

No. Utilization measures how much paid time goes to productive work. Productivity measures output per labor hour. A crew can be fully busy and still produce little, or be well organized and still lose hours to waiting. Looking at both tells you whether to fix scheduling and supply or crew method and supervision.

How often should I review crew utilization?

Weekly is the practical rhythm for most contractors, with a three-week look-ahead beside it. Weekly data is recent enough to change next week’s plan. Monthly review mostly explains what already happened.

Which hours should I leave out of the calculation?

It depends on the base you choose. For paid-hour utilization, leave nothing out. For realistic available hours, subtract holidays, PTO, training, safety meetings and weather downtime, as in the carpenter example above. Pick one base and keep it, so your trend stays comparable.

Sources